I’m a Chatterbox Adds Intrigue to Deep Division

I’m a Chatterbox Adds Intrigue to Deep Division

I’m a Chatterbox at Keeneland on October 11th – Keeneland Photo

I'm a Chatterbox at Keeneland on October 11th - Keeneland Photo
I’m a Chatterbox at Keeneland on October 11th – Keeneland Photo

With Beholder and Cavorting staking their claims as the leading older females in the country, and with Songbird and Carina Mia impressing in major races on opposite coasts, 2016 is already shaping up to be a great year for fillies and mares. On July 16th, the division got even more intriguing when I’m a Chatterbox scored an impressive victory in the ten-furlong Delaware Handicap (gr. I) at Delaware Park.

From some perspectives, her performance wasn’t all that eye-catching–she beat only five rivals, all of them unproven at the highest level, and her final time of 2:02.64 was modest and translated to a Beyer speed figure of just 98. But from a visual perspective, I’m a Chatterbox looked great and overcame a bit of trouble to win impressively.

I’m a Chatterbox’s troubles began at the start, when she stumbled slightly coming out of the gate and seemed to lose her balance, causing her to veer sharply to the left and crowd the three runners to her inside. There was quite a bit of jostling before jockey Florent Geroux managed to straighten her back out, and the incident left I’m a Chatterbox off the pace as the front-running Mei Ling sprinted to the lead. But Geroux didn’t hesitate and quickly sent I’m a Chatterbox to track the pace in second place, a decision that seemed brilliant as Mei Ling carved out modest fractions of :23.73, :47.72, and 1:12.82. Off those fractions, I’m a Chatterbox was going to be tough to beat, and while Fleur de Lis Handicap (gr. II) winner Paid Up Subscriber unleashed a determined rally in the homestretch, I’m a Chatterbox was never in serious danger of being caught and crossed the wire in front by 2 1/4 lengths.

After the race, an objection was lodged by the rider of Paid Up Subscribe alleging interference at the start, and while the head-on replay showed that Paid Up Subscribe was bumped soundly during the jostling, the stewards chose to let the results stand. Given that Paid Up Subscriber had clear aim at I’m a Chatterbox in the homestretch but wasn’t able to get closer than two lengths, and given that Paid Up Subscriber’s didn’t seem to lose early position as a result of the incident, I think the stewards made a good decision.

Now the question is whether I’m a Chatterbox can continue her ascension through the division and challenge for the Eclipse award as champion older female. She was among the leading three-year-old fillies last year with three graded stakes wins to her name, and if not for a disqualification in the Coaching Club American Oaks (gr. I), she would have a grade I win at Saratoga to her name. As it stands, the Delaware Handicap made I’m a Chatterbox a two-time grade I winner and she’s 2-for-3 overall this year. Of course, Beholder could pretty much sew up the division title if she wins the Pacific Classic (gr. I) against males for the second straight year, but I’m a Chatterbox looks poised for a strong season in her own right, and if she can pick up a grade I win at Saratoga, it could place her in a strong position heading into the Breeders’ Cup Distaff (gr. I), although shipping to California and defeating Songbird at her home track will not be an easy task.

Another highlight over the weekend was the victory by Cupid in the Indiana Derby (gr. II). The Bob Baffert-trained son of Tapit had shown great potential when winning the Rebel Stakes (gr. II) at Oaklawn earlier this winter (defeating future Belmont Stakes winner Creator in the process), but Cupid had surgery to correct a breathing issue after he tired to finish off the board in the Arkansas Derby (gr. I), and his first race since then–a last-place finish in the Easy Goer Stakes at Belmont–had some questioning whether Cupid could be trusted to return to form.

In the Indiana Derby, Cupid didn’t get off to the best start from post position ten, but when jockey Rafael Bejarano asked him for speed, Cupid rushed up to take a narrow lead after an opening quarter-mile in :23.44 seconds. He continued to duel for the lead through an intense half-mile in :46.75, then kept up the pressure through six furlongs in 1:10.86, which gave him a clear lead. At this point, it was clear that the real Cupid had shown up, and when he turned for home with a decisive advantage, it looked as though he was on his way to an easy victory.

However, the race wasn’t over yet. The Player, coming off of two straight wins at Churchill Downs, was rallying in the center of the track and gaining ground fast. Cupid, refusing to switch to his right lead, began drifting in and out, unable to shake clear of his late-running rival. The Player kept coming, but never got within three-quarters of a length of Cupid, who dug deep when challenged and turned back The Player to prevail in hard-fought fashion.

The final time of 1:43.30 for 8.5 furlongs resulted in a Beyer speed figure of 94, and the performance stamped Cupid as a colt to watch during the second half of the season. Time will tell if he will gain consistency with more experience and maturity, and he might end up being best as a Grade III/Grade II runner rather than an elite Grade I horse, but he’s already won two major stakes races and earned nearly $900,000, an admirable record for any horse.

Midnight Storm holds off a late run from Ashleyluvssugar to win the Eddie Read Stakes (gr. II) at Del Mar - © BENOIT PHOTO
Midnight Storm holds off a late run from Ashleyluvssugar to win the Eddie Read Stakes (gr. II) at Del Mar – © BENOIT PHOTO

In any case, Cupid adds further depth to Baffert’s already strong group of three-year-olds, which includes Iowa Derby (gr. III) winner American Freedom (targeting the Haskell Invitational), recent Santa Anita allowance winner Arrogate (possible for the Jim Dandy Stakes), and the sensational sprinter Drefong (heading for the Bing Crosby Stakes.)

I’d also like to briefly mention Midnight Storm, who was flat-out game in winning the nine-furlong Eddie Read Stakes (gr. II) at Del Mar. The distance might be a little beyond his best, but after being closely pursued through modest fractions, Midnight Storm found enough left in the tank to grit out a half-length victory over Ashleyluvssugar, with Flamboyant–making his first start since a solid fifth-place finish in the Dubai Turf (UAE-I) in March–another neck back in third. Midnight Storm has had issues with consistency in the past, but has now won two major races in a row and seems to be back on track. At his best, he’s definitely shown flashes of brilliance.

If you enjoyed this article, be sure to sign up for email newsletters and special offers from The Turf Board!

Follow J. Keeler Johnson ("Keelerman"):

J. Keeler Johnson is a writer, blogger, videographer, and all-around horse racing enthusiast who was drawn to the sport by Curlin's quest to become North America's richest racehorse. A great fan of racing history, he considers Dr. Fager to be the greatest racehorse ever produced in America, but counts Zenyatta as his all-time favorite. He lives in Wisconsin and also writes for the Bloodhorse.com blog Unlocking Winners.

Leave a Reply

1 Comment on "I’m a Chatterbox Adds Intrigue to Deep Division"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Eric Rickard

Cupid ran well and it was good to see. The player looks to have room to improve. I believe that was his first two turn race and he looked like he needed it.